HP is Stuck in the Past While Amazon Looks to the Future

I had two rather interesting news stories in myadvertising). Then MagCloud will print and bind it in
email this morning.very high quality, in whatever quantities you want
- From the WSJ: Amazon's Kindle 2 Improves the(even one at a time), and send it directly to your
Good, Leaves Out the Badreaders.
- From BNET.com: HP's MagCloud: The Greatest,I'm sure it's a remarkable technical achievement,
or Dumbest, Idea Everbut who cares? To me, MagCloud, is like a
The Kindleweb-enabled buggy whip. Being in the cloud does
We all know what the Kindle is. Amazon now hasnot automatically make something a relevant or
over 250,000 books, newspapers and magazinesuseful service.
you can wirelessly download to their digital reader.Print on demand is dead
After years of product failures (remember theExcept for limited niches, the idea of print on
RocketBook?); it appears that the age of thedemand is an old idea that has come and gone.
digital reader is finally here. You can argue aboutMagCloud is a solution to a problem that few
the Kindle's price point ($359) and its designpeople are trying to solve.
features (no backlit screen); but you can't argueThe biggest challenge facing newspapers and
about its relevancy.magazines today is not finding more efficient
The entire concept of media delivery is changing.ways to produce physical documents. Their
The San Francisco Chronicle is about to go out ofchallenge is to find ways to create robust online
business, Philadelphia no longer has a daily paper,revenue streams that can fund their editorial
and the Tribune Company is in bankruptcy. Thedepartments and content creation.
Kindle is one of many innovative responses to theAre they just trying to sell more ink?
new realities of information aggregation andIt is remarkable, that a company as innovative as
distribution.HP would dedicate so many resources developing
HP's MagCloudMagCloud. Or maybe it's just a round-about way
MagCloud, on the other hand, is much less wellto sell more HP inks. I don't know. But if you want
known. The idea is pretty simple. HP provides ato live in the Cloud - you better have something
highly feature rich online environment in which youmore substantial to support you.
can create your own magazine (with or without